All phases of post-judgment and appellate litigation, as well as trial support and monitoring.
Our appellate practice handles the full spectrum of appellate advocacy, from briefing and argument in state and federal appellate courts to strategic trial-level engagement that positions cases for success on appeal.
Insurance Coverage-Related Appeals
Insurance Coverage-Related Appeals
We represent insurers in appeals involving complex insurance coverage issues in state and federal courts across the country, advancing positions that help shape coverage law and protect our clients’ interests.
Casualty Appellate Practice
Casualty Appellate Practice
While the firm’s focus is insurance coverage and representing those in the insurance industry, certain matters involve issues or exposure of such significance that clients request our direct involvement on behalf of the insured. In such cases, we handle the appeal to safeguard both the insured’s position and the insurer’s broader business and industry considerations.
Trial Monitoring
Trial Monitoring
We frequently monitor high-profile and high-exposure trials, providing real-time assessments of developments, identifying significant appellate issues, and ensuring arguments are preserved for post-trial briefing and appeal.
Appellate Trial Support
Appellate Trial Support
When a case warrants a more active role before or during trial, our appellate team partners with trial counsel on dispositive motions, pre-trial strategy, directed verdict arguments, jury charge conferences, and post-trial briefing. This integrated approach ensures that critical legal issues are framed effectively for the appellate record.
EXPERIENCE
-
Repeated molestation claims against religious organizationThe New York Court of Appeals adopted our position that repeated sexual molestations constituted separate occurrences and must be equitably allocated across all years in which they took place. The Court also concurred that our client had not waived its right to litigate these issues.
Case Study
Representative Appellate matters include:
- Secured affirmation on appeal that an insurer did not violate eight provisions of the Kentucky Fair Claims Handling Act, including failure to settle, in connection with an underlying case that involved electrocution of a worker in a mine in rural Kentucky.
- Persuaded the Tenth Circuit to affirm summary judgment in favor of an excess insurer on the basis that $14 million in underlying tort judgments arising from a car accident were not against an insured as the insured car dealership did not own the car within the meaning of the excess policy at the time of the accident.
- Obtained affirmation of summary judgment in favor of a municipal entity, arguing that the Illinois Tort Immunity Act applied to preclude recovery for injuries sustained on municipal property.
- Reversed judgment against insurer, obtaining appellate ruling that insured was not entitled to coverage because its payments to Colombian terrorists were not accidental and injury had occurred outside coverage territory.
- Successfully challenged denial of client’s right to intervene to vacate default judgment against insured.
- Convinced the Seventh Circuit to affirm summary judgment in favor of an insurer that rescinded a policy based upon material misrepresentations in the insured’s application.
- Monitored trial and collaborated with trial counsel to obtain jury verdict finding that an insurer owed no coverage for several class-action settlements involving defective roof shingle warranty claims, and successfully defended the verdict on appeal.
- Obtained affirmation of summary judgment for insurer because advertising injury coverage does not include patent infringement claims.
- Persuaded the Second Circuit to affirm summary judgment that an insurer owed no coverage obligation to an insured that failed to comply with conditions precedent to coverage by providing untimely notice of an underlying claim.
- Successfully defended meat supplier in a wrongful death and subsequent commercial litigation involving contractual indemnity.
- Handled post-trial briefing and secured affirmance of bench trial verdict finding that insurer had no duty to indemnify an underlying jury verdict stemming from insured’s product defects because they did not constitute an occurrence under Texas law.
- Reversed Frye challenge to plaintiff’s expert witnesses’ reliance upon a SPECT scan to diagnose plaintiff’s closed head injury.